Press Release Video Marketplace Broadband

Online Video Copyright Decision Could Benefit Consumers and Competition

July 16, 2015 ,

Today, District Court Judge George Wu issued a preliminary decision finding that FilmOn, an online video service, is entitled to a compulsory copyright license. Public Knowledge has long advocated for regulatory parity for online video services, and applauds this decision.

The following statement can be attributed to John Bergmayer, Senior Staff Attorney at Public Knowledge:

“If upheld, this decision could help bring more competition to the video marketplace. Similar services shouldn't be subject to totally different rules depending on whether they’re offered over coaxial cable, fiber, satellite transmissions, or online.

“Although we disagreed with the Supreme Court's decision in Aereo, it's the law of the land. In that decision, the Court indicated that if a service appears to a viewer to be like a cable system, it ought to be treated like one under the law.

“In Aereo's case, that meant it was liable for copyright infringement. But copyright law also contains a compulsory license for cable systems, which allows them to broadcast programming without getting individual licenses from programmers, provided they follow FCC guidelines. It is logical that if cable-like systems should be treated as cable systems under the law, this should apply to the compulsory license, as well as to liability issues.

“Even if this decision is not followed, it should focus attention on the disparate treatment under the law between traditional cable systems and online services.”